Direct Sales Aid

Mary Kay vs Monat vs Scout & Cellar Wines

9,923 people have looked at this comparison.

Lowest cost to start

Mary Kay ($35)

Highest personal commission

Mary Kay (50%)

Longest track record

Mary Kay (since 1963)

Best rated by members

Monat (5.0 ★)

The company
FoundedLongevity is the first thing the industry looks at.
1963 · 63 yrsBest
2014 · 12 yrs
2017 · 9 yrs
Headquarters
Addison, TX
Doral, FL
Napa, CA
Reps are called
Beauty Consultants
Market Partners
Consultants
Estimated repsCompany-reported field force size.
1,700,000
15,000
300
Cost to start
Starter kitWhat you pay to begin selling.
$35–$125Best
$99–$650
$49–$99
Sales to earn the kit backMinimum kit ÷ minimum personal commission. Lower is better.
$117 in retail sales
$330 in retail sales
$409 in retail sales
How you get paid
Personal commissionYour cut of what you sell yourself.
30–50%Best
30–45%
12–25%
Downline commissionOverrides on sales made by people you recruit.
13%
3–12%
3–8%
Plan typeSingle-level pays on your sales only; multi-level adds overrides on a team.
Multi-level
Multi-level
Multi-level
On Direct Sales Aid
Member ratingPublished reviews from Direct Sales Aid members.
4.947 reviews
5.027 reviewsBest
3.02 reviews
Consultants listed
News articles
None
Fan votesReaders of this comparison picking a favourite.
0
0
0
Your pickOne vote per comparison.

Swap or add a company

How to read this comparison

  • Starter kit is the up-front purchase to begin selling. Some companies also charge an annual renewal or a website fee; check the company page.
  • Personal commission is your cut of your own retail sales. Downline commission is what you earn on sales by people you recruit; a plan with no downline pay is single-level, one with overrides is multi-level.
  • Sales to earn the kit back divides the minimum kit by the minimum commission. It is the retail volume you must sell before the kit has paid for itself, before any other costs.
  • Most multi-level plans publish an income disclosure statement. Ask for it, and read it, before you sign. Typical participants earn far less than the top ranks.
  • Figures are company-reported and can change. Spot something out of date? Tell us.

What members say

Monat
Monat
Dez Mirelda wrote 5 years ago

I have been a hairstylist including a salon owner for 15 years. I myself have had the worst case scenario hair for 8 years. I was introduced to this product because a couple of my clients were on it when I had no idea what it was. I noticed instantly a change in their hair and it intrigued me. A few months later I tried the products on myself and a few select customers… Six months down the road I replaced all the products I was currently carrying in the salon with strictly MONAT. It truly is the only haircare I have ever experienced that actually Does what it says it’s going to do #TRUELOVE

Mary Kay
Mary Kay
Ciara Peyton wrote 6 years ago

I’ve been apart of Mary Kay for 2.5 years ! I’m a Senior sales Director ☺️ However, the team commission statement on here is incorrect! We get 4-36% commission + our 50% on sales profit. Which would make us Number 1 for pay if all the rest of the companies are correct!

Scout & Cellar Wines
Scout & Cellar Wines
Hr wrote 6 years ago

The wines are overpriced and over-hyped. They are sourced from well-known domestic/import wineries and passed off as having a standard of higher quality than what the original winery produces. Reps from S&C can TELL you that they are of higher quality, but anyone can do a little digging and easily be able to determine what large wineries they are sourcing from and decide if you want to spend 3x the price for a S&C wine just because it's "Double Lab Tested" <-- means nothing, the other wineries are using the same fruit. Also, there's NO SUCH THING as a "Level 3 Sommelier." Yikes! :/...

Scout & Cellar Wines
Scout & Cellar Wines
Yvette wrote 8 years ago

The selection of wines is wonderfully diverse and are hand picked by a level 3 sommelier. They are also independently lab tested to ensure they adhere to the Scout & Cellar strict standards of: ZERO added chemicals, ZERO synthetic pesticides used in growing of the grapes, ZERO GRAMS OF ADDED SUGAR (you would be surprised how much sugar is added in commercial wines) and low sulfites. You'll want to try these wines and become hooked on drinking clean crafted! It makes a world of difference in how you feel.

Monat
Monat
Brian & Ann-marie Miglionico wrote 8 years ago

I have been losing my hair for nearly 18 years now, some areas were down to skin. Not wanting to go with chemical based products or surgery I decided to shave completely. Late last year we discovered MONAT and the promise behind an all natural, chemical free, essential oil-infused hair care line (from shampoo & conditioner to shave line, hair replenishing and regrowth) we were sold. I have to say much to my surprise I have regrown nearly 40% of hair in the back, and slowly have been seeing results in front (this area has been bald for 12 years). We are customers and Market Partners for l...

Monat
Monat
wrote 8 years ago

Monat is an awesome company to work for. They walk you through everything step by step. Lots and Lots of support. Not to mention the products are wonderful!!

Le-Vel Thrive

Featured consultant

Crissann Campbell

Le-Vel Thrive20%+ commissionOtho, IA

Hi, I'm Crissann! As a Top Leader with Le-Vel for 12+ years, I've loved helping people feel their best. From premium nutrition for energy, digestive health, weight management healthy aging to exosome skin repair... and now NEW Le-Vel RX with clinicia